{"kind":"regulens.evidence_pack","version":1,"generated_at":"2026-10-07T14:16:48.024874+00:00","product":{"id":"prod_7f6d5d454689","name":"Herbal Drink Powder","product_type":"food_beverage_powder","origin":"ID","packaging":"250g plastic pouch","ingredients":[{"normalized":"ginger","amount":null,"unit":null,"name":"ginger","unnormalized":false},{"normalized":"sodium_benzoate","amount":300.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","name":"sodium benzoate","unnormalized":false}],"target_markets":["market_de","market_id"],"compliance_status":{"market_id":"attention_required","market_de":"non_compliant"},"compliance_upcoming":null},"findings":[{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"fail","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":150.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":150.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_298cea42d1ad","available":true,"text":"E 210-213 | Benzoic acid — benzoates | 150 | (1) (2) | excluding dairy-based drinks","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.9997,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.9989,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_71000e5ce68f","available":true,"source_name":"EU Annex II — 14.1.4 Flavoured drinks","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:31.556000+00:00","content_sha256":"4c5f72b2c845cd1188d3ce60454e783e2560e8e0299af7c2e89b1f884483d89f"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":"2036-10-08","comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_29bef4281d9a","available":true,"text":"For users of the additive and premixtures, feed business operators shall establish operational procedures and organisational measures to address potential risks resulting from their use. Where those risks cannot be eliminated by such procedures and measures, the additive and premixtures shall be used with personal respiratory, eye and skin protective equipment.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"needs_review","reason":"unit_unconvertible","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_389d0ee10119","available":true,"text":"Kementerian update: untuk minuman masuk EU, batas sodium benzoate sekarang lebih rendah. Katanya mulai berlaku tahun ini.","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.4747,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.049,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":0.2},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_351c97d285a5","available":true,"source_name":"WA forward","source_type":"social_chat","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":null,"url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-23T06:45:19.797000+00:00","content_sha256":"57dd660e78e864774008ff6f93a800a57c8c9b868ab8b759840ea112f9d1cb76"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_3dab24bbee5d","available":true,"text":"For users of the additive and premixtures, feed business operators shall establish operational procedures and organisational measures to address potential risks resulting from their use. Where those risks cannot be eliminated by such procedures and measures, the additive and premixtures shall be used with personal protective equipment, including skin and breathing protection.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_584b3a09012d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2091","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-22T23:00:18.838000+00:00","content_sha256":"53a14aecce738098100dcd46da0b432a2be608f8518c4612c7c811fc56559d45"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":"2026-02-16","comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_445fc803a21a","available":true,"text":"For users of the additive and premixtures, feed business operators shall establish operational procedures and organisational measures to address potential risks resulting from their use. Where those risks cannot be eliminated by such procedures and measures, the additive and premixtures shall be used with personal skin, eye and breathing protective equipment.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_7575db5a42e4","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2070","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:23.797000+00:00","content_sha256":"59cd015b80fe1dc50f2b2146e7511b513a97e5606cf948c75b2a50ff89fca614"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"fail","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":200.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":200.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_47b7af771566","available":true,"text":"| E 210-213 | Benzoic acid — benzoates | 200 | (1) (2) | only Sød … saft and sødet … saft |\n(1):  The additives may be added individually or in combination\n(2):  The maximum level is applicable to the sum and the levels are expressed as the free acid","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.8991,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.9971,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_87591c368ec5","available":true,"source_name":"EU Annex II — 14.1.2 Fruit and vegetable juices","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:49:40.955000+00:00","content_sha256":"874204fc038bcb13fcc1c9a2ae1df0c471ff5519fbdd92083b9748b1544cfb16"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_914317dcbc4b","available":true,"text":"In the directions for use of the additive and premixtures, the storage conditions and stability to heat treatment shall be indicated.","clause_type":"labeling","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"fail","reason":"prohibited","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_a28855b6dee7","available":true,"text":"The additive shall not be used with other sources of benzoic acid or benzoates.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":850000.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":85.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"percent_w_w"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_adf38a834ac3","available":true,"text":"Preparation of benzoic acid, thymol, eugenol, piperine having a content of:\n\n—\n\nbenzoic acid 80 %-85 %","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_bacf208e9d41","available":true,"text":"Compound feed and feed materials containing the feed additive referred to in paragraph 1, which are intended for chickens for fattening, chickens reared for laying, minor poultry species for fattening and minor poultry species reared for laying and which are produced and labelled before 8 October 2027 in accordance with the rules applicable before 8 October 2026 may continue to be placed on the market and used until the stocks concerned are exhausted.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_cb96bcb73696","available":true,"text":"For the determination benzoic acid in compound feed: Gas Chromatography Isotope Dilution Mass Spectrometry (GC-IDMS)","clause_type":"documentation","status":"active","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"fail","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":150.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":150.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_d6a02d2bfdbe","available":true,"text":"E 210-213 | Benzoic acid — benzoates | 150 | (1) (2) | only traditional Swedish and Finnish fruit syrups","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.9992,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.9973,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_54586034e46a","available":true,"source_name":"EU Annex II — 14.1.3 Fruit and vegetable nectars","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-31T13:52:01.482000+00:00","content_sha256":"6138c46c2f0823c7485bef481f7823b4cc0a40418ee26841ccc44f0feac3d069"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_de513a0505de","available":true,"text":"The preparation of benzoic acid, thymol, eugenol and piperine, as authorised by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/1426 and premixtures containing that additive, which are intended for chickens for fattening, chickens reared for laying, minor poultry species for fattening and minor poultry species reared for laying, and which are produced and labelled before 8 April 2027 in accordance with the rules applicable before 8 October 2026 may continue to be placed on the market and used until the stocks concerned are exhausted.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":990000.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":99.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"percent_w_w"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_e38ad1f0ef66","available":true,"text":"Benzoic acid ( 1 ) (≥ 99 % purity), C 7 H 6 O 2 , CAS number 65-85-0","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_f071f4a5ea31","available":true,"text":"In the directions for use of the additive and premixtures, the storage conditions shall be indicated.","clause_type":"labeling","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_584b3a09012d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2091","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-22T23:00:18.838000+00:00","content_sha256":"53a14aecce738098100dcd46da0b432a2be608f8518c4612c7c811fc56559d45"}},{"market_id":"market_de","jurisdiction":"EU","substance":"benzoic_acid","verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_f23592e41326","available":true,"text":"For the determination benzoic acid in the feed additive and premixtures: Reverse Phase High-Performance Liquid Chromatography coupled to an Ultraviolet detector (RP-HPLC-UV)","clause_type":"documentation","status":"active","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_57df3d08d27d","available":true,"source_name":"REGULATION (EU) 2026/2077","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"EU","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-09-18T23:00:25.117000+00:00","content_sha256":"1126e6b3d992472ab72939e7dd9a85f620e8196b4310e828503da80f6cb84aab"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":400.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":400.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_026fece0d48b","available":true,"text":"14.1.4.2 Minuman Berbasis Air Berperisa Tidak Berkarbonat, Termasuk Punches dan Ades Batas Maksimal 400 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":"2022-08-01","comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_1775fcf0d077","available":true,"text":"Secara hukum produsen bertanggung jawab atas mutu dan keamanan produk yang dihasilkannya. Apabila terjadi penyimpangan dan pelanggaran terhadap standar yang telah ditetapkan maka produsen dikenakan sanksi, baik administratif maupun pro justitia.","clause_type":"other","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_c5ba7f8c5875","available":true,"source_name":"Keputusan Kepala Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Nomor 104 Tahun 2022 tentang Pedoman Strategi Komunikasi, Informasi, dan Edukasi Obat dan Makanan","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-29T13:35:49.881000+00:00","content_sha256":"c500d3a9538ddd12da08bb2f592b61fefb46653604c05b4d6143db8cb495c883"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":"2026-12-01","comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":350.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":350.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_2bdcb3e03a32","available":true,"text":"Batas Maksimal Natrium benzoat (INS 211) untuk Kategori Pangan 14.1.4.1 Minuman Berbasis Air Berperisa yang Berkarbonat adalah 350 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat, berlaku mulai 1 Desember 2026.","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.743,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.1434,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_653e1faed7ff","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM Amendment 2026","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":null,"url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-23T06:46:37.402000+00:00","content_sha256":"4e93fdf6a7b3469779d6e611723dacc2c7e776877e7edfacfd912b66541e4fb7"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":1000.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":1000.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_2d466b620c8d","available":true,"text":"14.2.7 Minuman Beralkohol yang Diberi Aroma (Misalnya Minuman Bir, Anggur Buah, Minuman Cooler-Spirit, Penyegar Rendah Alkohol) Batas Maksimal 1000 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":600.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":600.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_48ca4e006aee","available":true,"text":"14.1.2.3 Konsentrat Sari Buah Batas Maksimal 600 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat dihitung terhadap produk siap konsumsi","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":400.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":400.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_6ee98eebd351","available":true,"text":"Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate), INS: 211. Golongan: Pengawet. Nomor Kategori Pangan 14.1.4.1 - Minuman Berbasis Air Berperisa yang Berkarbonat: Batas Maksimal (mg/kg) dihitung sebagai asam benzoat: 400.","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.7474,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":0.1579,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_52e6f4a2ac8a","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM Perka 11/2019","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":null,"url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-23T06:28:40.706000+00:00","content_sha256":"e2af38cf84f5d50a62917cfe826fcf5d6673c5e9626b39c276f494aa4476310a"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":600.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":600.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_72d4bc416c85","available":true,"text":"14.1.2.2 Sari Sayur Batas Maksimal 600 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":600.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":600.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_a105a61e1a82","available":true,"text":"14.1.3.4 Konsentrat Nektar Sayur Batas Maksimal 600 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":"2022-08-01","comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_a9f77b8dda60","available":true,"text":"Sistem pengawasan oleh pemerintah melalui pengaturan dan standardisasi, penilaian keamanan, khasiat dan mutu produk sebelum diizinkan beredar di Indonesia","clause_type":"certification","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_c5ba7f8c5875","available":true,"source_name":"Keputusan Kepala Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Nomor 104 Tahun 2022 tentang Pedoman Strategi Komunikasi, Informasi, dan Edukasi Obat dan Makanan","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-29T13:35:49.881000+00:00","content_sha256":"c500d3a9538ddd12da08bb2f592b61fefb46653604c05b4d6143db8cb495c883"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":null,"verdict":"needs_review","reason":"non_numeric_clause","effective_date":"2022-08-01","comparison":{"product_value":null,"limit":null,"unit":null,"product_value_as_entered":null,"product_unit_as_entered":null,"limit_as_written":null,"limit_unit_as_written":null},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b09932e98bfd","available":true,"text":"Sistem pengawasan internal oleh produsen melalui pelaksanaan cara-cara produksi yang baik atau good manufacturing practices agar setiap bentuk penyimpangan dari standar mutu dapat dideteksi sejak awal.","clause_type":"certification","status":"active","confidence":1.0,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":1.0,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_c5ba7f8c5875","available":true,"source_name":"Keputusan Kepala Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Nomor 104 Tahun 2022 tentang Pedoman Strategi Komunikasi, Informasi, dan Edukasi Obat dan Makanan","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"watched_source","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-29T13:35:49.881000+00:00","content_sha256":"c500d3a9538ddd12da08bb2f592b61fefb46653604c05b4d6143db8cb495c883"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":900.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":900.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b16982e1f095","available":true,"text":"14.1.4.3 Konsentrat (Cair atau Padat) Untuk Minuman Berbasis Air Berperisa Batas Maksimal 900 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat dihitung terhadap produk siap konsumsi","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.8,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.5,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":600.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":600.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b36ce8269d8e","available":true,"text":"14.1.2.1 Sari Buah Batas Maksimal 600 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"conflicted","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":1000.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":1000.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b4ccba53d7e6","available":true,"text":"14.1.3.3 Konsentrat Nektar Buah Batas Maksimal 1000 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat dihitung terhadap produk siap konsumsi","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":400.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":400.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b5efe251a796","available":true,"text":"14.1.4.1 Minuman Berbasis Air Berperisa yang Berkarbonat Batas Maksimal 400 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}},{"market_id":"market_id","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","substance":"sodium_benzoate","verdict":"pass","reason":null,"effective_date":null,"comparison":{"product_value":300.0,"limit":600.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","product_value_as_entered":300.0,"product_unit_as_entered":"mg_per_kg","limit_as_written":600.0,"limit_unit_as_written":"mg_per_kg"},"rule":{"clause_id":"clause_b6079cfa9047","available":true,"text":"14.1.5 Kopi, Kopi Substitusi, Teh, Seduhan Herbal, dan Minuman Biji-Bijian dan Sereal Panas, kecuali Cokelat Batas Maksimal 600 mg/kg dihitung sebagai asam benzoat (untuk produk-produk cair siap minum)","clause_type":"numeric_limit","status":"active","confidence":0.9,"confidence_breakdown":{"parse_quality":1.0,"self_consistency":0.75,"authority_tier":1.0},"needs_review":false,"review_reasons":[]},"source":{"document_id":"doc_90be253d6f80","available":true,"source_name":"BPOM 11/2019 — Natrium benzoat (Sodium benzoate)","source_type":"official_regulation","jurisdiction":"ID_BPOM","origin":"library","url":null,"read_at":"2026-08-28T17:23:32.164000+00:00","content_sha256":"5d025cc807c602a94609ae7c358901c2f0d6775eb4b7bccdb64f1181b2db0f59"}}],"history":[{"occurred_at":"2026-08-31T19:17:01.910000+00:00","event_type":"product_created","before":null,"after":{"ingredients":[{"normalized":"ginger","amount":null,"unit":null,"name":"ginger","unnormalized":false},{"normalized":"sodium_benzoate","amount":300.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","name":"sodium benzoate","unnormalized":false}],"target_markets":["market_de"],"name":"Herbal Drink Powder","workspace_id":"ws_demo","product_type":"food_beverage_powder","origin":"ID","packaging":"250g plastic pouch"},"cause":null,"triggered_by":"api"},{"occurred_at":"2026-08-31T19:17:03.683000+00:00","event_type":"product_status_changed","before":{"market":"market_de","status":null},"after":{"market":"market_de","status":"non_compliant"},"cause":{"document_id":"doc_71000e5ce68f","clause_id":"clause_298cea42d1ad"},"triggered_by":"impact_engine"},{"occurred_at":"2026-08-31T19:26:33.720000+00:00","event_type":"product_updated","before":{"ingredients":[{"name":"ginger","amount":null,"unit":null,"normalized":"ginger","unnormalized":false},{"name":"sodium benzoate","amount":300.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","normalized":"sodium_benzoate","unnormalized":false}],"target_markets":["market_de"],"name":"Herbal Drink Powder","product_type":"food_beverage_powder","origin":"ID","packaging":"250g plastic pouch"},"after":{"ingredients":[{"name":"ginger","amount":null,"unit":null,"normalized":"ginger","unnormalized":false},{"name":"sodium benzoate","amount":300.0,"unit":"mg_per_kg","normalized":"sodium_benzoate","unnormalized":false}],"target_markets":["market_de","market_id"],"name":"Herbal Drink Powder","product_type":"food_beverage_powder","origin":"ID","packaging":"250g plastic pouch"},"cause":null,"triggered_by":"api"},{"occurred_at":"2026-08-31T19:26:35.763000+00:00","event_type":"product_status_changed","before":{"market":"market_id","status":null},"after":{"market":"market_id","status":"attention_required"},"cause":{"document_id":"doc_c5ba7f8c5875","clause_id":"clause_1775fcf0d077"},"triggered_by":"impact_engine"}],"coverage":{"findings":31,"rules_no_longer_on_file":0,"sources_no_longer_on_file":0},"limitations":["This pack is not signed. Its hashes show the content has not changed; they do not establish who produced it.","It reports what ReguLens read. A regulation nobody uploaded and no watched source published is not represented here.","A verdict marked needs_review was not decided automatically and carries no assertion of compliance."],"content_hash":"9844eced70d25afebee7e32f5ed7fc58fcea5c1839570296fa10c0e5b30b1e31","trace_id":"2b3ec286fa8c4541a9d6e3b43cbdb073"}